Showing posts with label proxy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label proxy. Show all posts

Sunday, August 23, 2009

No Comment

In May, the SEC proposed an amendment to the process that gives shareholders the right to insert proposals, and alternative director slates, onto corporate proxies (more here). Last weekend John Coates hepped me to the onslaught of comment letters that followed. He told me he'd signed a letter suggesting a slightly higher threshold than the 1% proposed by the SEC (Jay W. Lorsch et al, 8/13/09). He also told me that there was another letter from another group of law professors saying they thought 1% was just fine (Lucien Bebchuk et al, 8/17/09).

My first thought was that this sounded like a lot of fighting over pretty small numbers. The difference between the current 10% fee and 1% probably adds up, but the difference between 1% and 3%, or 5%? So, I went to Google Finance to see how much money 1% really is. I picked a couple of very large companies to start: Google, IBM, and AT&T, and I did the math. IBM has a market cap of $157 billion so 1% of that is $157 million. That's the minimum price to get one's proposal before the eyes of IBM shareholders. To me, that sounds like a shitload of money - maybe even a couple of shitloads - more than your average crazy has laying around his bunker. The numbers for Google and AT&T are similarly large - they won't have to worry about a flood of alternative director slates.

Smaller companies, however, probably will - a company with a market cap of $250 million would have an entry fee of $250,000. Not exactly spare change to the American Nazi Party, or the Black Bloc, but certainly low enough so that every hedge fund in town could float its own slate. So this is maybe a receipe for chaos, but what the hey ... how else do we find out what happens?

Friday, May 15, 2009

Update #3: Lies

Well, not lies exactly - the Corporate Counsel blog analyzed a report in Bloomberg that the SEC is considering a 1 percent threshold for its shareholder access proposal and found the report not credible.

Since we're talking about the Corporate Counsel blog and things that might not be as they seem, Corporate Counsel blog has also posted a draft of Charles Schumer's Shareholder Bill of Rights. Wachtell Lipton has already issued a memo in criticizing the bill (via Race to the Bottom) *sigh*.

Friday, April 24, 2009

Uninstructed Voting Gets Marching Orders

The Wall Street Journal is reporting that the SEC has decided to approve the NYSE's re-proposed amendments to Rule 452. Rule 452 allows brokers to vote shares on routine matters if shareholders don't tell them how to vote. The amendment would classify director elections as non-routine. As I blogged last month, the SEC has gotten lots of comment letters on the proposal. No official word from the SEC so far.

Tuesday, April 21, 2009

AAARRRGGGGGHHHH!!!!!

If you're going to be in Charlotte on April 29th, the most entertaining show in town will be at the Belk Theater - Bank of America's annual meeting. The price of admission is only $8.73 (that's BofA's share price as of this moment). There are 11 items on the agenda including two competing say-on-pay proposals (via Corporate Counsel blog).

It has been a long road to the final proxy. BofA has been the subject of at least ten no-action letters regarding shareholder proposals. Bad management decisions (cf Merrill Lynch) left BofA shareholders pretty ticked. It looked like the wind was behind a bunch of governance proposals (like the separation of chair and CEO: via Race to the Bottom) that usually get shut out of the party and end up hanging around outside trying to look tough. But, as has happended so frequently during this crisis, opposition appears to be crystallizing around personality instead of process.

Ken Lewis probably needs to go, but let's not take our eye off the ball (again) - this crisis won't get solved with pitchforks and flaming torches.

If you can't be in Charlotte, BofA reminds you that "you may listen to a live audiocast of the meeting on our website at http://investor.bankofamerica.com at 10:00 a.m., local time, on April 29, 2009."

Friday, April 17, 2009

Isn't That Special?

Today's WB Legal Currents has a substantial discussion of shareholder meetings - special and, you know, not so special - and the SEC's 14a-8 no-action letter process for shareholder proposals.

While you're there, be sure to click on the link to "Voting Swaps: Hedge Funds' Three Card Monte." An article about how issuers are trying to combat vote swapping among shareholders. People are marvelously inventive.

Monday, December 8, 2008

Shareholders Do it By Proxy

2009 is approaching and we're all getting ready for the merriest time of year: proxy season. There have been a number of developments of note and most center around rule 14a-8. 14a-8 is a mechanism allowing shareholders to get their proposals on the ballot at a company's annual meeting. Since proposals from shareholders generally make management do stuff they don't want to, management tends to fights back by asking the SEC's permission (via no-action letter) to exclude such proposals.

On November 7th, the SEC issued Staff Legal Bulletin 14D providing guidelines under 14a-8 for proposals directing the Board to amend the issuer's charter.

A group of law professors, led by Lucien Bebchuk, is suing Electronic Arts over its exclusion of a proposed resolution creating internal corporate guidelines for 14a-8 proposals. Link here to a post on Harvard Corporate Governance blog for more info and links to the briefs.

Shareholders of Alaska Air Group have proposed that the company amend its charter to limit the company's potential damages in a private lawsuit based on rule 10b-5. This has never been tried, but at least one law professor theorized that it is possible. The courts will decide, I suppose. Click to link to the proposal (via Securities Docket).

SEC Currents has a slightly weirder roundup of shareholder proposals including: Monsanto's proposed loyalty oath and Apple's attempt to avoid an environmental sustainability report.

Finally, the New York Law Journal recently published Charles Nathan's seasonal predictions.

Friday, December 5, 2008

Bank of Amerrillca is Go!

No periods today! The New York Times is reporting that the shareholders of Merrill Lynch and Bank of America have approved the merger of their respective companies. For them that's lookin', the final proxy statement was filed 11/3/08 on form DEFM14A and the S-4 is dated 10/2/08. The NYT article links to the press releases.