Showing posts with label SEC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SEC. Show all posts

Monday, August 31, 2009

I'd Like to Teach the World to Sing ...

Only two more days until the SEC and the CFTC begin their "harmonization" meetings. Okay, again from the top - and Mary, in E this time.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Open Meeting Thrills!

Apparently, there was much excitement at today's SEC open meeting. Compliance Week reports that the Commission voted to approve the NYSE's proposed ban on discretionary voting by brokers (see this post for more on discretionary voting). The vote was 3-2 along party lines.

FT Alphaville notes that the Commission also agreed to institute a say-on-pay requirement for TARP-recipient institutions.

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Reading the Tea Leaves on Regulatory Reform

It has been widely reported that within the next few weeks the administration will unveil a new, comprehensive financial markets regulatory scheme. Speculation about the scope of the proposal has been intense. In last week's New York Times, Stephen Labaton reported that the administration probably wouldn’t recommend rolling all four bank regulators up into one agency, but that a new agency for credit card and mortgage regulation was still a possibility. In the background, administration officials have been meeting with a constellation of experts to hammer out details. In one recent meeting, a group of academics, policy analysts and researchers was asked questions that provide some insight into the administration’s general approach. The questions, combined with recent news reports also suggest that the regulatory agenda has been finalized, but they’re still fighting about money and political turf.

The Treasury Department has previously aired two pieces of the puzzle: resolution authority and regulation of the over-the-counter derivatives market. The resolution authority proposal was outlined in a March 26th press release (TG-72). The press release asked Congress for an FDIC-like power to seize and dismember institutions deemed a risk to the entire financial system. Left unresolved was which agency would be the resolver. Resolution authority appears still to be on the table: the experts were asked where the administration could obtain the money to carry out resolutions of institutions that aren’t banks. The FDIC’s resolution process is paid for out of a fund derived from payments made by FDIC-insured institutions.

Secretary Geithner has carefully avoided answering questions about who would swing the sword of resolution, but he has stressed, on several occasions, the need for a new regulatory entity that could police institutions that pose a risk to the financial system generally. He has not, however, been specific about this new agency’s power or role. A number of players have leaped into that void. In late March, a bipartisan bill was introduced in the House and Senate (HR 1754, S 664) that would create a council composed of the heads of all the financial regulatory agencies. This group (called the Financial Stability Council) would be in charge of assessing systemic risk. This bill framed the terms of the debate – should systemic risk be overseen by a loose collection of regulators, or should there be a new agency? Sheila Baer at the FDIC and Mary Schapiro at the SEC (who would be members of a financial risk council, but would lose turf if a new agency were created) have, unsurprisingly, expressed approval of the council idea. The experts were also asked to weigh in on this question. Is a systemic risk council an acceptable compromise, they were asked, or do we need a new regulatory agency?

Over-the-counter derivatives regulation, on the other hand, seems squared away. On May 13th, Secretary Geithner sent a letter to Senator Harry Reid outlining the administration’s proposal for OTC derivatives regulation. According to a source with knowledge of the meeting, the experts were not asked about OTC derivatives regulation.

The US financial regulatory system was constructed piecemeal in response to a variety of historical events. The result of this ad hoc approach is a patchwork of jurisdictions that overlap in some areas but don’t cover other areas at all in others – a problem is known as “regulatory fragmentation.” On the evidence of the last few questions, regulatory fragmentation is still on the agenda. The experts were asked how much they thought regulatory fragmentation contributed to the current crisis. They were also asked to describe how well the existing system protects consumers and investors. Last week, a report from the Associated Press (“Fed Would Serve as Risk Regulator under Obama Plan,” AP Datastream, 5/28/09) described a draft regulatory scheme that would create two major regulatory agencies – one protecting consumers and one protecting investors. The investor protection agency would be created by merging the SEC and the CFTC. Merging or eliminating regulatory agencies has proved to be a reasonably hot political potato. Every agency, it seems, has a champion in Congress. These champions stand to lose power if their pet agency is curtailed. The New York Times article spent several paragraphs addressing the “political cost” of correcting regulatory fragmentation.

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

The Big Squeeze

If I said "section 10(b) of the '34 Act," you'd know what I was talking about, but if I mentioned section 78j you probably wouldn't be sure, right? They're the same section, of course, but when securities law professionals talk about the '34 Act's anti-fraud provision they say 10(b), a designation that comes from chapter 404 of the laws of 1934 (48 Stat 881), and not 15 USCA 78j. The reason no one uses the United States Code citations for the securities laws is because they are so damned convoluted (the Trust Indenture Act, for example, is 15 U.S.C. § 77aaa – 77bbbb). Unfortunately, 10(b) isn't good enough for the Blue Book so sometimes we need to find the full citation.

The "find a securities document" tool on the Westlaw Securities Practitioner page will translate for you, but this post isn't about how to find the right citation, its about how this mess happened in the first place.

The United States Code is maintained and updated by a House department called the Office of the Law Revision Counsel (OLRC). They are also responsible for enacting the Code into positive law. The OLRC originated during what I like to call the “codification wars” of the nineteen-twenties. In 1919 Colonel E. C. Little, Chairman of the House Committee on the Revision of Laws, embarked on a project to codify federal statutes and enact them into positive law. Col. Little’s completed codification, organized into 60 titles, was passed by the House in 1920. It went on to the Senate and was killed. Why, the Senators wondered, would Little want to repeat the disaster of 1873? In 1873 Congress repealed all existing federal statutes and replaced them with a codification. The Revised Statutes of 1873 contained so many errors and that it had to be amended immediately in 1875 and again in 1877. The House was undeterred by the Senate’s qualms. It re-proposed and passed Col. Little’s codification twice more. Upon its second presentation, the Senate Committee on the Revision of Laws reported that the bill had 600 errors, omissions, and inaccuracies. The Senate Committee proposed a compromise in the form of a joint commission to revise the laws.

In the period between the 1873 codification and the 1919 attempt, commercial publishers had filled the gap. Both West and Thomson produced useful and frequently-updated codifications. The Senate asked these publishers to assist in producing an official codification. The resulting document, shortened to 50 titles, passed the House in 1926. The Senate remained unconvinced and refused to enact the bill. In the end, the Senate couldn't be convinced to replace existing statutes with a potentially error-filled codification. Instead, the Senate amended the bill to provide that the codification was “prima facie” evidence of the law and that existing statutes remained in force.

According to Peter LeFevre, the present Law Revision Counsel, this situation was meant to be a temporary fix giving the House Committee on the Revision of Laws (now charged with upkeep of the codification) time to rectify errors and begin piecemeal enactment of the United States Code as positive law. This temporary fix slowly calcified. In 1946 the committee was demoted to subcommittee. In 1974 it became a government agency of sorts. A 1974 law elevated the Law Revision Counsel from an officer of the House Judiciary Committee to the head of a separate office reporting to, and appointed by, the Speaker of the House. Three men have held the post since 1974: Edward Willet, Jr. (1975 – 1996), John R. Miller (1997 – 2004), and Peter LeFevre (2004 – present).

When Congress enacts a new law, lawmakers don’t normally consider where the law will fit in the Code. In its role as the Code’s custodian, the OLRC decides where laws go. Organizing and maintaining the Code is an enormous job that occupies most of the OLRC staff. Charles Zinn, Law Revision Counsel in the 1950’s, described the process as “a matter of opinion and judgment” driven by “where we think the average user will look.” LeFevre agrees that although the OLRC follows policies and precedent, the driving force behind placing a law in the Code is where people “will expect to find it.”

I asked LeFevre why the securities laws have such difficult citations. He didn’t know, but he told me that laws are added to titles in chronological order, unless they are related to laws that have already been enacted. The securities laws are squeezed into Title 15 of the US Code between Chapter 2 and Chapter 3. Chapter 1 contains antitrust laws: the Sherman Act of 1890, followed by the Clayton Act of 1914. Chapter 2 contains the Federal Trade Commission Act of 1914 and Chapter 3 contains the Trade-Mark Act of 1905.

Why are the securities laws of 1933 – 1940 jammed in between the FTC Act and the Trade-Mark Act? The answer lies in the Securities Act of 1933. When Congress enacted the ’33 Act, the first of a series of planned securities laws, it charged the Federal Trade Commission with enforcing the Act. A year later Congress enacted the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, which created the Securities and Exchange Commission. The ’34 Act removed the securities laws, including the ’33 Act, from the jurisdiction of the FTC and placed them within the oversight of the SEC. Unfortunately, the ’33 Act had already been placed in the Code, right next to the FTC Act. Instead of moving the ’33 Act, the Law Revision Counsel decided to let things stand and proceeded to cram all of the securities laws in the space between the FTC Act and the Trade-Mark Act. To add insult to injury, in 1946 Congress enacted the Lanham Act and repealed Chapter 3.

To learn more about the Office of Law Revision Counsel, visit its website. The legislation governing the OLRC may be found at 2 U.S.C. 285 – 285g. Those interested in the positive codification process should read Charles Zinn’s address to the Law Librarians’ Society of Washington, D.C. at, 45 Law Libr. J. 2 (1952) and Richard J. McKinney’s excellent “United States Code: Historical Outline and Explanatory Notes."

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

The Missing Week #2: SEC stuff

On May 20th, the 1% rumor came to pass when the SEC voted to propose a new shareholder proxy access rule (14a-11) that would allow shareholders holding more than 1% of an issuer's stock to nominate board candidates. Wachtell Lipton was quick to criticize the proposal for "federalizing" shareholder access to proxy materials. RiskMetrics was over the moon. More from Nixon Peabody.

Because the Department of Justice is investigating two SEC lawyers for insider trading the SEC announced it is taking steps to improve its internal checks for insider trading.

The Corporate Finance Blog has a nice summary of the potential application of SEC rules to all those gee-whiz social media tools of which our corporate leaders have recently become so fond.

Corporate Law Prof has a post on the joint SEC / Department of Labor hearing on a class of mutual funds, called "target date funds," which change their asset mix depending on an investor's age.

Monday, April 27, 2009

Spring Tweets!

A recent article in the WSJ discusses the use of twitter among large corporations and potential issues with the SEC. The SEC has joined in this new social media trend and is an active twitterer (SEC: http://twitter.com/SEC_Investor_Ed). Not quite the following as Ashton Kutcher, but give it time.

Last year in early August 2008, the SEC issued an
interpretive release regarding guidance on the use of company web sites. Press release and video are also available.

Don't forget, you can also follow the Speculative Debauch* on twitter:
http://twitter.com/specdebauch



Thursday, April 16, 2009

The SEC This Week

Staff Accounting Bulletin 111, replacing topic 5:M, Other Than Temporary Impairment of Certain Investments in Equity Securities and related Technical Amendments and Recodification of Financial Reporting Policies.

Mary Schapiro's statement at the credit rating agency roundtable and related request for comments.

Comment period re-opended for intra-agency privacy rules.

Meredith Cross, formerly of Wilmer Hale, is the new head of Corporation Finance.

Adoption of updated EDGAR Filer Manual.

Friday, April 3, 2009

SEC Update

The Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board proposed a pilot program adding continuous disclosure from municipal issuers to its electronic disclosure system, EMMA.

At the end of April, Erik Sirri, Director of the Division of Trading and Markets, is leaving the SEC to return to academia.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

SEC Publishes New '34 Act Guidance

The Corporate Counsel Blog reports that the SEC has updated the Compliance and Disclosure Guidelines for '34 Act rules with special focus on 10b-5.

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

SEC Update

Erik Sirri, Director of the Division of Trading and Markets testifies about observations and lessons learned from the CSE program:

* no parent company liquidity pool can withstand a "run on the bank."
* there is a need for focus on illiquid assets held by financial firms
* Recent events have proven the limitations of certain risk metrics such as Value-at-Risk
* critical financial and risk management controls cannot just exist on paper

Julie Zelman Davis has been named Deputy Director of the agency's Office of Legislative and Intergovernmental Affairs, where she will serve as a key liaison between the Commission and Congress.

The SEC will hold an open meeting on April 8th to discuss whether to propose a short sale price test (does this mean the uptick rule?)

New CDS counterparty alert: they're coming fast and furious. Today's victim? The Chicago Mercantile Exchange.

Commissioner Elisse Walter offers a conservative agenda for regulatory reform: regulate OTC derivatives by repealing the CFMA, require hedge fund managers to register as investment advisers, merge the SEC and the CFTC.

Ethiopis Tafara, Director of the SEC's Office of International Affairs offers a more radical prescription.

Monday, March 9, 2009

SEC Update

The SEC had a busy week! It seems Mary Schapiro is starting to reveal her regulatory priorities, viz:

Counterparty Like its 1999: the SEC has approved another central counterparty for credit default swap transactions and even though, as the release admits, they can only regulate "those CDS that are not swaps" (what does that "S" stand for?), they're game.

Round 'n' Roundtable: on April 16th, yet another discussion of how to regulate credit rating agencies. Mary Schapiro calls it "clearly one of this agency's most important responsibilities."

Tweeeet: the SEC has brought in a consulting firm to help evaluate and improve the way it handles whistleblower complaints.


Briefly Noted: lists

Securities Docket reports that the D&O Diary has begun a running list of Stanford-related litigation. D&O Diary presently maintains a list of Madoff litigation.

The most recent issue of Fortune has an interview with SEC Chairman Mary Schapiro. You can read it for free here.

The Corporate Counsel Blog reports that Felicia Kung is the new head of rulemaking at the SEC Division of Corporation Finance.

Reuters reports that the Rohm Haas / Dow Chemical trial is coming soon and both companies have submitted witness lists.

Reuters also reports that rumored zombie bank Citigroup has taken the top spot in Thomson Reuters' global M&A league table for 2008. It looks like we're talking less Night of the Living Dead and more Land of the Dead.



Thursday, February 26, 2009

NYSE Applies to Suspend $1 Listing Floor

The New York Stock Exchange has applied to the SEC to temporarily suspend Listed Company Rule 802.01C. 802.01C requires a company be delisted if its stock trades below a dollar for 30 days in a row.

The new application extends last month's lowering of the market capitalization rules for continued listing in Listed Company Rule 802.01B.

Other SEC News

Michael A. Conley has been named Deputy Solicitor in the Appellate Group of the SEC's Office of the General Counsel.

Commissioner Elisse B. Walter gave a speech before the PLI's corporate governance seminar titled "Restoring Investor Trust through Corporate Governance."

Kayla J. Gillan, a founding Board Member of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board and former General Counsel for CalPERS, has been appointed Senior Advisor to the Chairman.

TARP Doesn't Catch Sloppy Drafting

The Division of Corporation Finance has released guidance on Section 7001 of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, which amended Section 111(e) of the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act to "permit a separate shareholder vote to approve the compensation of executives." This is what those wags in securities land call "say on pay." Makes me think of Lyndon Johnson: "Hey hey, say on pay, how many kids did you kill today?"

The only teensy oversight in this provision is that it lacks an effective date. Chris Dodd sent a letter to the SEC expressing his opinion that this provision "became effective on February 17, 2009 and applies to preliminary or definitive proxy statements."



Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Reading the Signs

I've been looking at the pronouncements from the administration's inner circle searching for indications of what they think the SEC's place should be in a revised regulatory structure. I have found a preference for co-operation between agencies that suggests that the SEC may have to cede its place as the world's most important securities regulator.

The most significant indications come from a report called "Financial Reform: A Framework for Financial Stability" produced by the G30 Working Group on Financial Reform. The Framework is important because of who wrote it: Timothy Geitner, Paul Volcker and Lawrence Summers are all members of the Working Group. Volcker called it "a reasonable indication of the direction in which we might go." Uh huh - I'll take it anyway. Core Recommendation 2 calls for enhanced international coordination to "modify material national differences in standards" and "develop processes for joint consideration of systemic risks". This is in line with Lawrence Summers' expressed desire to prevent regulatory competition by curbing what he calls a regulatory "race to the bottom." The alternative, Summers suggests, is "global co-operation to raise standards."

Monday, February 23, 2009

Honey, I Shrunk the SEC!

The Treasury Department has been churning out important rules and guidance - the Homeowner Affordability Plan, a tough joint statement about bank liquidity. Even the Office of Management and Budget has released major guidelines relating to the various economic recovery plans.

And what has the SEC been doing? Enforcement. Look at the last week's worth of the"what's new" page on the on the SEC's website and you'll see SRO rulemaking and enforcement.

I know there's a rulemaking moratorium, but is it possible that we're seeing part of the administration's regulatory restructuring scheme? Is the SEC going to become mainly an enforcement agency?

Honey, the SEC Shrunk Itself!

The SEC has made a few, largely unsuccessful, stabs at regulating hedge funds and credit rating agencies and it now appears, from this Reuters report, that the head of the European Central Bank intends to propose global regulations for those types of entities. Jean-Claude Trichet said: "Let me stress that both initiatives on rating agencies and hedge funds warrant strong international coordination."

Maybe this is the new administration's real vision for the future of regulation: international cooperation between regulators. A system like this is already working in Canada. Even though each province has its own regulatory body, each body has enacted the same rules. These "national instruments" are mutually agreed upon and then enacted locally - almost like treaties. Disclosure documents are filed on SEDAR, a jointly-operated electronic filing system.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

SEC Grab Bag

In other SEC news:

Andrew Vollmer, acting general counsel, will resign.

Who said backdating investigations were winding down? Research in Motion and four of its executives have been charged with stock option backdating.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Other News from Securities Blogs

Race to the Bottom reviews Mary Schapiro's first speech and finds it just right.

Stockbroker Fraud Blog notes that the SEC is asking for comments on a FINRA rule proposal regarding brokerage house liquidity requirements.

Jim Hamilton notes that the bailout bill repeals the very controverisal IRS Notice allowing banks to offset losses when they buy other banks. For more about IRS Notice 2008-38 click here.

NYT DealBook reports that Alan Greenspan says he was "mystified" by the subprime market. Why should he be different from anyone else?

Okay, permit me one Madoff - this also from DealBook - foundations that invested with Madoff may be subject to excise taxes for not vetting their investments properly.