Showing posts with label accounting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label accounting. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

Every Good Boy Deserves Fudge

In virtually every other country in the world, financial statements are prepared according to the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) set by the London-based International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). The IFRS is, if you will, the metric system of accounting.

In mid-July, the IASB proposed a simple new way of apportioning financial instrument valuation methods. The new standard establishes only two security catergories: loans, and instruments that act like loans (valued at cost), and everything else (marked to the market) The Economist called the compromise “a superior sort of fudge.”

We should probably be paying attention to what IASB does because, at least pre-crisis, everyone agreed that their system should replace GAAP. Canada shed GAAP last year and in February the SEC announced a framework (which they called a “road map” – release no. 33-8982) for full IFRS adoption in the United States by 2014.

FASB and the IASB have been working on joint projects since at least 2002 and in October they created a joint Financial Crisis Advisory Group.

If you’d like to get a jump on the IFRS-ification of US accounting (never too early!) this AICPA website has a guide to IFRS and the creepily-named “convergence” of GAAP and IFRS. If you’d like a head-to-head comparison, Warren Gorham & Lamont’s treatise International Accounting, Financial Reporting, and Analysis is available on Westlaw (WGL-INTLACCT).

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Accounting Research

As an expansion on yesterday's discussion of SEC accounting and FASB, I offer a quick research guide to GAAP materials for public companies.

Because of the variety of sources, I have found it useful to start with an accounting treatise. There are two Warren Gorham & Lamont treatises on Westlaw that cover accounting for public companies. Both treatises discuss the entire GAAP hierarchy from Regulation S-X to the FASB Emerging Issues Task Force. The SEC Accounting and Reporting Manual (WGL-SECMAN) is organized by disclosure type. There are sections on registering securities and filling out form 10-K. The Handbook of SEC Accounting and Disclosure (WGL-SECHDBK), on the other hand, is organized, like a convential auditors handbook, by financial statement type (the first chapter is "Balance Sheets.")

Reasearching primary FASB materials is about to change dramatically. In June, FASB published SFAS No. 168: The FASB Accounting Standards Codification (FASB ASC). The FASB ASC, which comes into force in the third quarter of this year, replaces pretty much every existing GAAP document and flattens the GAAP hierarchy to two levels (in FASB ASC, and not). Basic level access to a database containing FASB ASC is free.


Monday, July 13, 2009

Looking for Acceptance

GAAP stands for "Generally Accepted Accounting Principles." The loose, easy sound of this belies the fact that GAAP is mandatory. The Code of Conduct of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants forbids accountants from departing from "principles promulgated by a body designated by the AICPA Council to establish such principles." The AICPA's promulgator of principles is the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) an accounting think tank organized in 1973. FASB, based in Norwalk, Connecticut, is controlled by a trust called the Financial Accounting Foundation.

GAAP isn't one document - it is a dizzying array of more than 2000 accounting "pronouncements" issued by a variety of authorities. The pronouncements are arranged in a strict hierarchy laid out in FASB Statement No. 162, The Hierarchy of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. At the top of the heap are FASB's Statements of Financial Accounting Standards (SFAS).

The securities laws (e.g. '33 Act sections 7 & 19(a)) give the SEC control over accounting standards for public companies, but the SEC has always delegated this power to private organizations. Upon FASB's organization the SEC transferred to it power to set accounting standards. Before the organization of FASB, the AICPA had SEC approval to set standards (thus, AICPA "Accounting Principles Board Opinions" from before 1973 carry the same weight as SFAS). The SEC also describes FASB pronouncements as "generally accepted," but to the SEC the phrase has a very different meaning - the SEC is indicating that it has provisionally agreed to use FASB standards, but reserves the right to set them aside. In the words of the SEC, they are "recognized as authoritative in absence of any contrary determination by the Commission."

The SEC's control over public company accounting standards was recently reinforced by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act which required reaffirmation that FASB was sufficiently independent to act as the financial accounting designee of choice (release no 33-8221).

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

FASB in 2010!

FASB has also been very busy of late. While I was on vacation, they released FAS 166 and 167 about accounting for off balance-sheet entities (more from FEI Blog) and today they began a five-city "listening tour." Presumably, this means they won't talk? The listening tour is Hillary Clinton's invention. Is FASB going to run for the Senate?

Friday, April 3, 2009

Diminishing Rate of Return

The Financial Accounting Standards Board just can't stop explaining fair value. Yesterday, FASB adopted three new Staff Positions about fair-value accounting. This post on the Corporate Counsel Blog has links to the documents and several articles on the changes.

Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Fair Value in a Hurry!

In response to a request from Congress, the Financial Accounting Standards Board has rushed out new guidance for interpreting the FASB mark-to-market accounting rule (FAS 157). The guidance takes the form of two proposed Staff Positions titled "Determining Whether a Market is Not Active and a Transaction is Not Distressed," and gasp, "Recognition and Presentation of Other-Than-Temporary Impairments." The comment period is open until April 1st so you'll need to hurry.

SEC Acting Chief Accountant James L. Kroeker has provided additional guidance in a recent speech.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Two Weeks at Today's Prices

FEI's Financial Reporting Blog describes an exchange (at a Congressional hearing) between FASB Chair Robert Harz and Rep. Gary Ackerman where Harz says he'll try to have final mark-to-market rules ready in three weeks. SEC Chief Accountant James Kroeker also agreed to the fast-track timeline.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

FASB's Shadow

Tammy Whitehouse of Compliance Week has a good post about FASB's recent decision to retreat, again, from fair-value accounting for contigencies in business combinations. "It's our version of Ground Hog Day," says FASB Chair Robert Herz - looks like six more weeks of "reasonably estimated".

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Though this be madness, yet there is method in ’t

The Daily Deal has an interesting discussion of how an SEC exemption allowed a $50 billion "enterprise" to be audited by a three-person (one retired, one a secretary) accounting firm in New City, New York (a hamlet of the Town of Clarkson, whatever that means).

The Sarbanes-Oxley Act amended section 17(e) of the 34 Act to require SEC-registered firms be audited by accounting firms registered with the SOX-created Public Accounting Oversight Board. However, the SEC immediately exempted private firms from this requirement (Release 34-48281) and kept extending the waiver every year (34-50020, 34-52909, 34-54920) because it was, "consistent with the public interest and the protection of investors."

As reported by the New York Times, the latest ban was allowed to expire at the end of 2008. Just in time, too.

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Other News from Securities Blogs

Race to the Bottom reviews Mary Schapiro's first speech and finds it just right.

Stockbroker Fraud Blog notes that the SEC is asking for comments on a FINRA rule proposal regarding brokerage house liquidity requirements.

Jim Hamilton notes that the bailout bill repeals the very controverisal IRS Notice allowing banks to offset losses when they buy other banks. For more about IRS Notice 2008-38 click here.

NYT DealBook reports that Alan Greenspan says he was "mystified" by the subprime market. Why should he be different from anyone else?

Okay, permit me one Madoff - this also from DealBook - foundations that invested with Madoff may be subject to excise taxes for not vetting their investments properly.

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Blog Roundup: Looking on the Bright Side

This post on Naked Capitalism discusses an under-reported *upside* of mark-to-market accounting. In the third quarter, banks reclassified $610 billion in assets as "level 3" under FAS 157. The reclassification gives them much more flexibility in determining what the assets are worth.

The Center for Audit Quality (via Compliance Week) has good news for issuers who have lost accelerated filer status because their stock price is in the toilet: you don't have to file that SOX 404 auditor certification!

To be an accelerated filer, an issuer must have at least $70 million in market capitalization (market capitalization is number of shares outstanding multiplied by share price). For example, Astronics Corporation (Nasdaq:ATRO) fell below the accelerated filer cut-off in late November when its share price got below $8.22. At its current price ($8.10 x 8.51 million shares out) its market cap it $68.94 million. Earlier this year, it had a market cap of $455 million! Flotek Industries (NYSE:FTK) has had an even harder come down. In January it was a "large accelerated filer" with a market cap of $842 million. Now, after a 90% decline in share price, it has a market cap of $71.07 million.

SOX 404 has been the subject of much issuer consternation and the SEC repeatedly delayed its application to non-accelerated issuers.

Securities Docket has a post about the SEC's announcement that it is planning to distribute the fair fund from the Bear Stearns market-timing case. There's also a link to the text of the distribution plan.

Race to the Bottom has a nice summary of the corporate governance provisions of the Auto Industry Financing and Restructuring Act (HR 7231) as well as a status update.

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Corporation Finance Posts Financial Reporting Manual

SEC transparency took another giant leap forward yesterday when the Division of Corporation Finance posted their internal accountant's handbook on the web. The Financial Reporting Manual has been around since 1990, but it wasn't available to the public (though most law firm libraries seem to have a much-photocopied bootleg). Back in November, John White promised this was going to happen: "(SEC Chief Accountant) Wayne (Carnall) is in the process of updating our training manual for the Division’s accountants and, in light of the level of outside interest in getting copies of this document, we plan to publish the manual on our website in the near future."

The Manual hasn't been updated since 2000, but Compliance Week reports that Wayne Carnall called the changes "very limited." Going forward, the Manual will be updated every quarter.

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

Briefly Noted: FAS 157, JP Morgan, Deal Points Study

SEC Chairman Cox thinks mark-to-market (FAS 157) is a good system, says the New York Times.

Reuters reports that the JP Morgan / Bear Stearns merger has survived a court challenge.

The Harvard Corporate Governance blog provides the full text of the ABA report on merger agreement terms, aka the "Deal Points" study. As well as the full text of the court's opinion in JP Morgan / Bear Stearns matter.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Tax Change Leads to Investigation at Treasury

Last week Senator Charles Grassley sent a letter to Eric Thorson, the Treasury Department's Inspector General, asking Thorson to investigate the "facts and circumstances" leading to the issuance of IRS Notice 2008-83. Notice 2008-83, issued days before the economic rescue law was enacted, changed the tax treatment under IRC section 328(h) of losses realized after one bank acquires another. At issue are losses from selling instruments for less than they cost (say, for instance, mortage-backed securities). 2008-83 removed the ceiling on the amount of such losses that can be deducted against income. For a smarter and more detailed discussion see this memo written by Annette Ahlers of Pepper Hamilton LLP.

Grassley is concerned because so many former bankers were involved in drafting 2008-83. He thinks it suggests that treasury is giving preferential treatment to banks and that there may also be an appearance of conflict of interest when former bankers give huge tax breaks to other bankers. Grassley also mentions that this tax break actually made it possible for Wells Fargo to acquire Wachovia without any government money.

Today, the New York Times reports that Thorson has opened an investigation.


Tuesday, November 18, 2008

BNA Recap - CDS Clearinghouse, TARP Warrant Treatment

The November tenth issue of the BNA Securities Regulation Law Report summarizes, from an internal SEC document, the SEC's work on the recently announced central clearinghouse for credit default swaps. (40 SRLR 1860)

The same issue contains an interview with FASB member Leslie Seidman about accounting treatment of the warrants issued to Treasury through the TARP equity purchase program. FASB's letter to Treasury about accounting treatment of TARP warrants can be found here. (40 SRLR 1860)

Friday, October 24, 2008

FASB Staff Position Sparks War of Words

A couple of weeks ago, the Financial Accounting Standars Board (FASB) issued Staff Position 157-3. 157-3 interprets and clarifies Statement on Financial Accounting Standards number 157. 157, titled Fair Value Measurements, tells auditors how to value assets. 157-3 adds further guidance about valuing assets that aren't readily salable. 157-3 comes in the wake of a joint SEC-FASB clarification of 157 issued at the end of last month.

Immediately upon the release of 157-3, the American Bankers Association (ABA) wrote a letter to the SEC asking them to ignore 157-3. The ABA's complaint is that 157-3 uses unreliable bargain sale prices to value assets.

A few days later, the Center for Audit Quality wrote a letter to the SEC protesting strongly against calls, "to suspend fair value accounting."




Friday, October 17, 2008

Mark-to-Market Motivates Meeting

As reported by FEI, the SEC has announced a roundtable on mark-to-market accounting. In the same post, they report extensively on comments received as well as comment letters in the offing.

Also on the FEI blog, is this report on FSP FAS 157-3 Determining the Fair Value of a Financial Asset When the Market for that Asset is not Active - the latest clarification in the continuing saga of FAS 157.




Friday, October 3, 2008

Bailing Out of FAS 157

As I mentioned in an earlier post, there has been discussion about the role of the valuation rules of FAS 157 in the gruesome fate of many of our financial institutions. Even Newt Gingrich (via Forbes) has weighed in.

Section 132 of the bailout bill passed by the Senate and the House (2007 CONG US HR 1424, 10/1/08 engrossed amendment) would allow the SEC to suspend FAS 157. Section 133 of the bill would require the SEC to produce a report analyzing the role of FAS 157 in bank failures.


Wednesday, October 1, 2008

SEC & FASB "Clarify" FAS 157

More valuation news out of the SEC. Yesterday, the SEC and the FASB issued a joint clarification of FAS 157 (2008 WL 4411374). FAS 157: Fair Value Measurements, which went into effect in November, assigned "levels" to assets for valuation purposes. There was much agita that assets assigned "level-three" status would have to be written down. Also affected are AU 332 and SAB codification topic 5M.

For more, see this SEC Currents article.

Sunday, September 28, 2008

Was that Horse, Barndoor?

On the 26th, the SEC announced that it was terminating the Consolidated Supervised Entity (CSE) program of 2004. All the former CSEs are either defunct or have become banks regulated by the Fed.

Cox lays blame for the failure of CSE at the door of Congress. He says Gramm-Leach-Bliley should have given his agency the power to regulate companies that own investment banks more, though the SEC appears to have chosen to regulate them less.

CSE let highly capitalized broker-dealers use mathematical models, like Value-at-Risk, to value swaps and derivatives for purposes of the Net Capital Rule (15c3-1). The Net Capital Rule ensures that if a broker dealer goes under it will be able to pay its debts.

The CSEs were:

Bear Stearns
Goldman Sachs
Lehman Brothers
Merrill Lynch
Morgan Stanley