Showing posts with label explanations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label explanations. Show all posts

Monday, July 13, 2009

Looking for Acceptance

GAAP stands for "Generally Accepted Accounting Principles." The loose, easy sound of this belies the fact that GAAP is mandatory. The Code of Conduct of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants forbids accountants from departing from "principles promulgated by a body designated by the AICPA Council to establish such principles." The AICPA's promulgator of principles is the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) an accounting think tank organized in 1973. FASB, based in Norwalk, Connecticut, is controlled by a trust called the Financial Accounting Foundation.

GAAP isn't one document - it is a dizzying array of more than 2000 accounting "pronouncements" issued by a variety of authorities. The pronouncements are arranged in a strict hierarchy laid out in FASB Statement No. 162, The Hierarchy of Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. At the top of the heap are FASB's Statements of Financial Accounting Standards (SFAS).

The securities laws (e.g. '33 Act sections 7 & 19(a)) give the SEC control over accounting standards for public companies, but the SEC has always delegated this power to private organizations. Upon FASB's organization the SEC transferred to it power to set accounting standards. Before the organization of FASB, the AICPA had SEC approval to set standards (thus, AICPA "Accounting Principles Board Opinions" from before 1973 carry the same weight as SFAS). The SEC also describes FASB pronouncements as "generally accepted," but to the SEC the phrase has a very different meaning - the SEC is indicating that it has provisionally agreed to use FASB standards, but reserves the right to set them aside. In the words of the SEC, they are "recognized as authoritative in absence of any contrary determination by the Commission."

The SEC's control over public company accounting standards was recently reinforced by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act which required reaffirmation that FASB was sufficiently independent to act as the financial accounting designee of choice (release no 33-8221).

Thursday, July 2, 2009

Let's Pretend

In previous posts, I've talked about derivatives in general terms, but today I'd like to focus on the most widely used type of derivative - the swap. I'm going to use the example of a simple interest rate swap in a single currency (although, be warned - there are no simple swaps). For purposes of this discussion, let's pretend it is January of 2008 and you are the CFO of a medium-sized company.

You need to borrow $20 million from the bank. Your banker offers you a very good, fixed interest rate of 3.5% (50 basis points less than the current LIBOR rate of 4%) and you say yes. Your monthly interest payment is $70,000. Because you are a saavy user of the credit markets, you decide to enter into an interest rate swap to hedge your exposure in the event interest rates fall.

An interest rate swap is a fake transaction where two parties pretend to borrow money from each other. The only thing that prevents the transactions from being a wash is that one phony borrowing is at a fixed rate and the other is at a floating rate. The amount of the phony loan is called the "notional amount." Once a month, you and the other party get together and compare interest rate payments. The party with the higher payment turns over the difference.

Your swap is structured like this - you "borrow" $20 million from a third party (let's call them "Wasp") at the LIBOR rate and Wasp "borrows" $20 million from you at 3%. Therefore, Wasp's payment to you will always be $60,000, but your payment to WASP will vary with the LIBOR rate. At your initial settlement, you owe Wasp money. Your imaginary LIBOR-pegged payment would be $80,000. $80,000 minus Wasp's pretend payment of $60,000 = $20,000. You pay Wasp $20,000. In total, you end up handing over (to Wasp and the bank) $90,000. Not such a good deal for you, yet.

Then, the credit markets collapse and interest rates go down with them. Your 3.5% loan becomes a bad bargain, but your interest rate swap begins to bear fruit. At your next settlement, your LIBOR-pegged payment is down to 2% so Wasp owes you $40,000. If you apply this money to your bank loan, your reduce your interest payment to $30,000.

See how simple that is?

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Free Resources: from today's webinar

During today's National Library Week webinar, I mentioned a number of free resources that provide current awareness and/or explain concepts relating to the financial crisis.

Felix Salmon's blog - Felix is a Reuters columnist who blogs about the financial crisis. He covers one issue per day with good linking.

The Speculative Debauch - this blog is intended to provide current awareness and explanations for law librarians practicing in the securities / corporate law area.

Reuters DealZone - a business blog that covers the transactional market: hedge funds, private equity, LBO's and M&A.

Marketplace White Board - a series of entertaining videos explaining financial crisis terms like collateralized debt obligation and credit default swap.

Planet Money - a current awareness blog with a glossary of terms.

This American Life - two excellent, in-depth shows about the economic crisis: Bad Bank and Another Frightening Show About the Economy.

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Securities Law Explainifier #C: DERIVATIVE

A derivative is a financial instrument that derives its value from the value of something else. Essentially, a derivative is a bet on what the price of the underlying asset will do. There has been a fully-functioning derivatives market in the United States since the mid-nineteenth century. (see: Markham, “CONFEDERATE BONDS,” “GENERAL CUSTER,” AND THE REGULATION OF DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS, 25 Seton Hall L. Rev. 1 (1994))

A fixed-rate contract with a heating oil company is a derivative. That’s because the contract itself has value, but its value depends on the price of heating oil. Heating oil is the underlying asset. Imagine you typically use 100 gallons of oil during the winter and you sign a fixed-rate contract when the price of oil is $4 a gallon. The following week the price goes down to $3 a gallon. Your heating oil company owns a contract worth $100 (the difference between the market price of oil and the contract price). If the price of oil stayed at $4, the contract would be valueless, and if the price of oil went up to $5 the contract would be worth $100 to you.

Derivatives are often used as a hedge. Hedging is essentially making a bet and, just in case, also making the opposite bet. It’s like betting $100 on the long shot and $30 on the favorite. The potential gains are less, but so are the potential losses.

The main species of derivative are:

Forwards - an agreement to sell the underlying item at a set time, place and price (our heating oil contract is a forward).
Futures - like forwards, but with standard terms.
Options - a right to sell (put) or buy (call) the underlying item at a set price.
Swaps - an agreement to trade the cash flow from one transaction for another. Like this:
1. Party A borrows 30,000 US Dollars and party B borrows 15,000 UK Pounds.
2. A gives the 30,000 Dollars to B and B gives the 15,000 Pounds to A
3. A pays B's monthly payments and B pays A's monthly payments
4. At the end of the term, A and B exchange money again

The swaps market dwarfs the other derivative markets. Swaps exist in a constellation of sub-types: interest rate swaps (one party borrows money at a fixed rate the other at a floating rate), basis swaps (two different fixed rates), commodity swaps (one fixed, one based on the price of a commodity), and on and on. For more about derivatives I suggest:

Nagler, DERIVATIVES DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS: HERE WE GO AGAIN, 6 Cornell J.L. & Pub. Pol'y 441, (Winter 1997)

AN INTRODUCTION TO OTC DERIVATIVES, 848 PLI/Corp 121, (1994)

Friday, January 16, 2009

Securities Law Explainifier #B: INDENTURE


An indenture is a contract governing the rights of bondholders.

The word was coined to describe a medieval service contract (thus, someone who signed an indenture was "indentured"). Medieval indentures were written in duplicate on one big piece of paper and then cut apart. Each party got a half. The cut was intentionally made wavy, "indented," so that when the pieces were reunited, it was clear they were originals.

I can't explain how this term came to the world of corporate debt. If you know, please tell me!

The earliest corporate debt indentures created a trust for the benefit of bondholders. Issuer assets were placed in the trust and administered by a trustee for the benefit of the bondholders. So, if the issuer missed a payment the trustee could sell the assets. The indenture protected the bondholder's investment and guaranteed that all bonds were worth the same amount.

The Trust Indenture Act (15 USCA s. 77aaa) requires that debt sold to the public be governed by an indenture and that there be a trustee.

No assets are transferred in modern indentures. Instead, the trustee acts as the bondholder's representative. It oversees a trust containing the bondholder's contract rights. "Modern" is a relative term in the indenture context - the most important book on the subject, Commentaries on Model Debenture Indenture Provisions was written in 1965.

Let's look at an example: last year, General Motors Corporation entered into an indenture with The Bank of New York as trustee (ex. 10.3 to 8-K filed 2/25/08). The indenture is a 60-page contract. It contains very broad language about what kind of debt will be issued and very specific language about the duties of the issuer and the trustee. For example, if GM defaults the trustee is empowered to "declare the principal amount ... immediately due and payable" and to "instigate any action or proceeding at law," on behalf of the bondholders.

An indenture is meant to be a durable document. GM's previous indenture was signed in 1995. Also attached to the same 8-K is the first supplemental indenture (ex 10.4) which adds a new section to the indenture describing "4,372,500,000 - 6.75% Series U Convertible Senior Debentures."

Monday, January 5, 2009

Securities Law Explainifier #A: POISON PILL

Today I'm starting a series of posts that explain legal concepts that I wish someone had explained to me when I was a law librarian. After the discussion, some research tips. Coming soon: indenture, underwriter, derivative and multi-jurisidictional disclosure. If there's something you want explainified, let me know. Enjoy?

POISON PILL ZERO

To give you an idea of how a poison pill works, I’ll tell you the story of the very first poison pill …Once upon a time, in the go-go 80’s, Brown-Forman, manufacturer of Jack Daniels, decided that its liquor cabinet would not be complete without Lenox Inc., stodgy manufacturer of presidential china. The president of BF approached Lenox about a merger on friendly terms. The Southern ruffians were rebuffed. So, on June 8, 1983, BF launched a hostile tender offer at $87 per share, a 60% premium over Lenox’s market price. The next day Lenox shares shot up to $86.50.

Lenox hired Wachtell Lipton partner Martin Lipton to oversee its takeover defense. Lipton gets credit for inventing the poison pill. On June fifteenth, Lenox activated its pill. The board rejected BF’s offer and issued a “special cumulative dividend” to Lenox shareholders. The cumulative dividend was in the form of the right to purchase shares (called a share purchase right). Now watch closely: in the event that BF and Lenox merged the share purchase right would entitle the holder to buy, at a steep discount, Class A shares of Brown-Forman. Class A shares were the only voting shares of BF and they were held only by the Brown family. After the merger, the former stockholders of Lenox would control BF! How, I hear you ask, could Lenox think this would work? Contract law: if BF acquired Lenox, BF would become successor-in-interest to Lenox’s contracts. So, BF would be responsible for Lenox’s contract responsibilities.

This is a flip-over. No one has yet had the courage to challenge this mechanism in court. In my opinion, “poison pill,” with its images of a spy taking cyanide to avoid capture, is a deceptive name. This thing is more like the Trojan horse. You may be taking us over, but surprise, we’re taking you over, too! It also brings to mind the atomic bomb – a weapon so frightening that the bidder has no choice but to negotiate. A poison pill can be adopted by the board without shareholder approval. Once the pill has been activated, only the board can turn it off. In fact, the whole edifice rests on the power of the board to use the pill without resort to the shareholders. Starting with Moran v. Household Insurance in 1985, courts have consistently found that the adoption of a pill is within the board’s power under the business judgment rule.

The present model for poison pills follows the Lenox blueprint: the target issues share purchase rights. An event (or trigger) activates the rights. The activated rights give target shareholders power to complete a lucrative transaction that injures the bidder. A share purchase right is like a coupon – it is an option contract that offers to sell something at a discount. The rights are created and governed by an agreement between the company and a third party called a shareholder rights agreement. The third party is called the rights agent. The rights agreement sets out the mechanics of the pill. When the rights are created, they are “attached” to the common shares and can’t be exercised, if the triggering event happens, they “detach.”

What causes the rights to activate? A typical plan works this way:

TRIGGER 1: If there is a tender offer for a set percentage of the company’s securities the rights agent distributes the rights. Existing shareholders, except the bidder, are issued rights. As initially issued, rights have unfavorable terms.

REDEMPTION: Between triggers is a period called the “redemption window:” typically a few days. During that time, rights may be redeemed by the board for very little, often a tenth of a cent on the dollar.

TRIGGER 2: Closing by the bidder of a share purchase transaction activates the rights. Activation changes the terms from very unfavorable to very favorable.

And what does your share purchase right give you the right to purchase?

Flip-in rights: give the holder the right to purchase discounted shares of the target. Flip-in is also used to describe the first trigger.
Flip-over rights: give the holder the right to buy discounted shares of the merged entity, or of the acquirer.

EDGAR SEARCH TIPS:

Adoption or amendment of a poison pill is an 8-K event. Item 601 of Regulation S-K requires that an in-force shareholder rights agreement be attached as exhibit 4 to every registration statement and form 10-K.

WESTLAW RESOURCES

Treatises:

Corporate Anti-Takeover Defense: The Poison Pill Device (SECPILL). A handbook for drafting rights agreements, by Joy Marlene Bryan. Contains brief discussion, definitions, and sample language.

Special Study for Corporate Counsel on Poison Pills (CCPPILLS). A West publication containing discussion of the law and sample documents – it is updated every year and has a drafter’s checklist.

BNA Corporate Practice Series 6-3: Responses to Takeover Bids (BNACPS-RTB). This publication contains an overview of the process of responding to a takeover bid including a discussion of defensive mechanisms - updated monthly.

Reports:

Poison Pill Reports database from SDC Platinum (POISONPILL). Contains reports summarizing every pill ever adopted starting with Lenox Inc - updated daily.

For those that need to know the ending: BF managed to acquire Lenox for more than $400 million. In 2005, BF sold most of Lenox to Department 56 for $190 million. Wachtell Lipton respresented BF.