Showing posts with label SRO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SRO. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Tick ... Tick ... Tick ... Tick ... Tick ...

About twice a year I have a fit of ambition and sign up for listserves. Then, a few weeks later, I start getting those "your mailbox is over size limit" warnings and I unsubscribe. But I never give up, because I'm convinced listeserves are bursting with useful information that will make my job easier. It's just that when I spend time sorting through all that information I don't have time to do the job with which they ostensibly help.

Through it all, I have kept my subscription to the listserve from the Business & Finance Division of SLA, and last week it paid off again with a very useful discussion about intraday trading data.

A typical stock chart, whether acquired from Google Finance or Bloomberg, records the high, low, and closing price for one day's trading. If you need more detailed information about what went on during the trading day (bid, ask, individual trade size, etc.) you must use a more specialized source.

Intraday, of course, means during the course of one day. Intraday pricing is also known as tick-by-tick pricing. A tick is the minimum amount a stock exchange will let a security's price change. From 1792 until 1997 a tick was 1/8 of a dollar on every US stock exchange. In the 1990's that changed when the AMEX, and then the NYSE and the NASDAQ changed their minimum tick to 1/16 (also known as "a teeny"). This radical change lasted all of four years until the SEC blew it away by making the exchanges "decimalize" their trading - thus changing the minimum tick to one cent.

The collected wisdom of the SLA B&F list recommended the following sources (and I know of no others): NASDAQ Report Source, Francis Emory Fitch (which I always called plain old "Fitch"), and NYXdata. Fitch has the largest and deepest data. NYXdata is owned by the NYSE, but it covers NASDAQ otc, and the regional exchanges, NASDAQ Report Source only covers NASDAQ, but its cheaper than the others and you don't have to subscribe.

Monday, June 22, 2009

SRO = Crap Regulatory History

A couple of weeks ago, I was attempting to help a librarian research the history of an NASD rule. I was attempting to help because I couldn't actually help. While some of this may be chalked up to my own research skills, some blame must be laid at the door of the NASD. Researching rules promulgated by self-regulatory organizations is monumentally unpleasant. While I'm not able to offer a research panacea, I offer the following information to either (a) make such research easier or (b) help manage the expectations of your customers.

The first US stock exchange was organized in Philadelphia in 1790. The early exchanges were organized as private associations and were not subject to government regulation. So, when Congress was debating the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the exchanges lobbied hard to keep their self-regulatory status. A compromise was reached. The exchanges had to register with the SEC, but their self-regulatory powers were enshrined in law. They became quasi-governmental actors and custodians of the goals of the Exchange Act.

Section 19(b) of the Exchange Act also gave the SEC the power to abrogate SRO rules when necessary to further the Act's goals, but the SROs were not required to submit their rules for SEC approval. In the early days, the SEC took a "collaborative" approach to SRO regulation - they raised questions and conducted negotiations in secret. But, starting in the 1960's pressure began building to give the SEC more power to control exchange activities.

The Securities Act Amendments of 1975 required SROs to get SEC approval for any proposed rule change. It articulated the somewhat contradictory goals of "preserving" self-regulation while "the SEC ... play(ed) a much larger role ... to ensure there is no gap between self-regulatory preference and regulatory need."

What this means in practice is that any pre-1976 rule change is lost in the mists of time, but from 1976 forward, all SRO rules had to pass under the eyes of the SEC before taking effect.

There are two SRO rule approval processes - rules that articulate stated policies, fee changes, or SRO administrative procedures become effective immediately under section 19(b)(3)(A) of the Exchange Act. Other rules are reviewed by the SEC, usually by the Division of Trading and Markets, but in the case of "controversial" rules, by the full Commission. This second process, under section 19(b)(2) of the Exchange Act, requires publication, a comment period, and a notice of adoption in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act.

That's the good news. The bad news is that the SEC often publishes a summary of the amendment in lieu of the full text. So, even though that rule change you're looking for is probably somewhere in the Federal Register there is no guarantee it uses any of the key words in your search.

The SRO's themselves have made no attempt to create an historical record of rulemaking. Their idea of an annotation often starts with "amended by." They also have a tendency to reformat their rules without warning. For instance, the NASD rule I was "helping" with began its life as a "policy statement." In my experience, the only source for the history of an SRO rule is often an out-dated copy of the SRO's manual. If you haven't held on to those, its too late to start.

I'm talking about the past, of course, these days, SRO rulemaking looks much more like other kinds of administrative rulemaking. Also, much SRO rulemaking is now done by a new, joint NYSE-NASD regulatory body called FINRA.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

NYSE Reproposes Uninstructed Voting Amendment

If you don't fill out a proxy card, your broker can vote your shares any way he pleases, as long as the issue being voted on isn't "controversial." This is called "uninstructed" voting. This rule exists so that shareholder meetings can get quorum. Election of directors is considered non-controversial when there is no opposing slate.

In 2006, the New York Stock Exchange tried to amend its rule (Rule 452) about unistructed voting. It sought to take away the right of NYSE member brokers to vote uninstructed proxies for directors. The SEC did nothing and the proposed amendment died. Last week, the NYSE resubmitted the proposal.

Thanks to Race to the Bottom for its excellent coverage of this issue.

Thursday, February 26, 2009

NYSE Applies to Suspend $1 Listing Floor

The New York Stock Exchange has applied to the SEC to temporarily suspend Listed Company Rule 802.01C. 802.01C requires a company be delisted if its stock trades below a dollar for 30 days in a row.

The new application extends last month's lowering of the market capitalization rules for continued listing in Listed Company Rule 802.01B.

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Blue Chip Blood Bath

"Down, down down. Would the fall NEVER come to an end! 'I wonder how many miles I've fallen by this time?' She said aloud. Alice's Adventures in Wonderland

So far, Bloomberg reports, that the New York Stock Exchange may have to "temporarily ease" the requirement of Listed Company Rule 802.01C that all listed company stocks trade above ONE DOLLAR.

Far enough that many of the companies in the S&P 500 wouldn't be eligible for the list because they have insufficient market capitalization (via Bespoke Investment Group).

Thursday, February 12, 2009

Other News from Securities Blogs

Race to the Bottom reviews Mary Schapiro's first speech and finds it just right.

Stockbroker Fraud Blog notes that the SEC is asking for comments on a FINRA rule proposal regarding brokerage house liquidity requirements.

Jim Hamilton notes that the bailout bill repeals the very controverisal IRS Notice allowing banks to offset losses when they buy other banks. For more about IRS Notice 2008-38 click here.

NYT DealBook reports that Alan Greenspan says he was "mystified" by the subprime market. Why should he be different from anyone else?

Okay, permit me one Madoff - this also from DealBook - foundations that invested with Madoff may be subject to excise taxes for not vetting their investments properly.

Monday, January 26, 2009

Got Those Delisted Blues

Today's Corporate Counsel has a nice overview of how the NYSE and the NASDAQ have been adjusting their listing standards so they can come out of this mess with a few companies still listed.

Psssst ...

Legal Currents on the new FINRA anti-rumor rule.

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

NYSE Circuit Breakers Extended

The New York Stock Exchange has extended until March 27th the expiration of NYSE Rule 48. Rule 48 was adopted in December of 2007 (NYSE Info Memo No. 07-110) to allow the NYSE to delay opening if there is "extremely high market volatility that would have a Floor-wide impact on the ability of specialists to arrange for the timely opening."

In October of 2008, Rule 48 was amended (NYSE Info Memo No. 08-48) to provide a suspension of "market-at-close" orders. MOC orders are placed during the trading day but executed at the close at the closing price. Information Memo 08-48 also added an section 48.10 which provides that Rule 48 will expire at the end of 2008.

The NYSE says it is extending the expiration of Rule 48 so it can move the MOC part to Rule 123C.